I wanted very much to leave this story alone. However… ladies and germs, I present to you one of the things that’s wrong with the world:
Two men pleaded not guilty today to charges they created panic by placing “bomblike” electronic light boards displaying a cartoon character with an upraised middle finger throughout Boston. Assistant Attorney General John Grossman called the light boards “bomblike” devices and said that if they had been explosive they could have damaged infrastructure and transportation in the city. (from CNN.com)
Overall, I have found this story kinda silly – a horrible overreaction, but, well, it did get excellent PR for the cartoon.
What I don’t find funny is the phrase, “IF they had been explosive.” IF if if if IF IF IF. If I accidentally dropped a Seiko watch at the mall, it might have a detonator! Or poison gas! If I put a teddy bear at a vigil site, it might be a pipe bomb! Or soaked in anthrax!
And if my eclair was made of uranium and had a plutonium filing, it could kill me quickly rather than slowly clogging my arteries.*
One of the Boston officials noted yesterday that, basically, this was an unconscionable stunt in a post-9/11 world. And I can understand – certainly I respect – that first responders are the people who have to make the connections quickly, who have to look for danger, and who have to place their lives on the line to protect the rest of us, even when a situation appears innocuous.
But there’s a difference between watching for danger and seeking it out where none exists. There’s enough danger in the world without imposing it upon innocuous situations. I can’t say how I would have reacted, but I’d like to think I’d be able to call a spade a spade, a toy a toy, and an eclair an eclair. And I’d like to think I’d make certain the call was right before I shut down a city, created massive panic, and wasted so much time and money.
It’s a post-9/11 world, but it’s still a world. People can do the unthinkable, but that doesn’t mean you need to stop thinking.
Turns out this does fall under the scope of this blog. Massive panic is not how we are constituted. The inability to distinguish between a real threat and a cartoon character threatens us – as a people – as much as most violence. And the kind of thinking evidenced by this event can do tremendous damage.
* Thanks to my husband for the eclair idea.